Thursday, October 29, 2020

Question Response


❓❓❓Question:
The research showed the benefits of text-based communication, but do text messages also have negative effects on users' self-esteem? If so, under what circumstances?

---- Weikang Xiong 


------πŸ’¬---------πŸ’¬----------πŸ’¬-------------

Recommended Videos



This is a really cute and clear video that talks about ten points that text-based message would psychologically hurt people and their relationships.

πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―πŸ‘―

πŸ‘€The negative effect of text-based message

----------------------------πŸ’š-----------------------------

I believe texting can give people time to think about their reactions, talk to someone without showing up, and ultimately give them confidence.

However, while all this sounds good, texting and other forms of computer-mediated communication can also make people more anxious.

This is due to the fact that people can interpret the message in many ways.

A simple "conversation" may mean this, but research shows that similar vague texts can be interpreted negatively, causing anxiety.

If the conversation is in person, the recipient can interpret based on tone, facial expressions, and body language.

But in the text message, only words can be analyzed.

Based on a Sex, dating, and relationships writer, Natalia Lusinski, for Bustle, “I feel couples forget how to talk in real life, with all the texting and social media-updating that they do. They seem to know everything about each other and each other’s days already, so they don’t feel the need to talk much in person.”

Moreover, people will also try to build a fake identity through text-based communication. In this way, people's social interaction ability will decrease when they come to real-time or face to face communication. They will also be afraid of meeting people because all of the conversations by then will be instant.


---------πŸ’¬----------πŸ’¬----------πŸ’¬---------

❤πŸ’Ÿ"Paradox Effect"???πŸ’ŸπŸ‘Ώ

People who are addicted to text-message and social media are easy to fall into "Paradox Effect". It will generate the illusion of they are having more social engagement and are perform positively socially. However, it is really just an illusion!!!!πŸ’€



Also, based on a study in 2012, conducted by a psychologist at the University of California at Berkeley,  sending and receiving text messages boosted texters’ moods when they were feeling upset or lonely. 53% of them are more likely to generate the "Fear of Missing Out" (FOMO). 

πŸ’šRecommended ArticleπŸ’š

Sleepyteens: Social media use in adolescence is associated with poor sleep quality, anxiety, depression and low self-esteem

LINK: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0140197116300343

I also read a really interesting academic article about how social media affect people's sleeping quality and affect their self-esteem (or even mental health). All of that perspective that this article mentioned and I mentioned above are all the negative effects that it will lower people's self-esteem. However, I think those negative effects also associate with the poor use of social media and text messaging. There are lots of changes and improvement could be implemented for both children and adult users. Also, there is even some psychological treatment for people by using social media as support. So I believe social media and text messaging are multidimensional for people and this is a really interesting but also complicated topic to discuss on. 😍

Thanks so much for this interesting question! It really pushes me to search and dig into more resources. ❤




4 comments:

  1. Hello Jiawen,
    I agree with you that a text (or email) can often be interpreted in a way that was not intended, as it is just a stripped down means of communication. No one can see an accompanying smile, gesture or eye contact--and no, an emoji does not suffice, hah. I also think that a "curtly" written text can often come through as a power play, establishing a pecking order. For example, if someone doesn't write clearly, spell correctly or punctuate a message, I always feel (personally) like that is a bit of an insult. That's just me though!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Also, I am reading a book by Sherry Turkle: "Reclaiming Conversation: The Power of Talk in a Digital Age" ... you might be interested to check it out!

      Delete
  2. Hi Cathy! Thank you for answering my question. I agree with you that texting and other forms of online communication have both positive and negative effects on users' self-esteem. Meeting other people behind the computer gives us time to think about our responses and offers us the opportunity to connect with people who live far away. However, it is never the same as meeting someone in person. As you mentioned, virtual space gives us a buffer zone that allows us to hide our fear, emotions and even true identities. This reminds me of the application of VR in therapies. By leading patients into a virtual world that mimics the real world, therapists help patients overcome their fear gradually in a safe environment. As for negative effects, I think virtual communication leaves room for bullying, because users may think they are not responsible for what they say or do online. I think it is very important for designers to consider the pros and cons of online communication when they design products, so that their designs will serve users as intended.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Cathy! What an interesting topic. There is just so many ways texting can lead to confusion and misinterpretation. I think one of the more problematic aspects of texting is the inability to physically leaving a conversation you are uncomfortable having. Short of blocking someone, which is seen as an extreme form of personal rejection, sometimes the only option is to simply stop responding and hope the other party gets the hint. Often, the normal conventions of entering and exiting a dialogue are abandoned in the name of expediency. We have become conditioned in such a short amount of time to feel the need to read and respond to an incoming text even if it's from someone we may not want to talk to at that moment. To read a comment and NOT respond (leaving the sender on "Read" where they know you've read their message but have chosen not to respond) is almost universally interpreted negatively by the sender even if you were planning on responding in the future. I think we forget how important non-verbal social queues are to understand emotion and intent. A really fascinating subject.

    ReplyDelete

2045>

  What will happen in 2045???πŸ‘€ Scenario πŸ’ World 1: Trust Your Self πŸ’› " A highly individualized world of contingent and shift-ing all...